www.industrialheritageireland.info

Book Reviews

The 5 Minute Bell

The 5 Minute Bell
PUBLISHER Frank O'Donoghue


AUTHOR/EDITOR * Author - Frank O'Donoghue


DETAILS
Published 2012
ISBN 9780957448407
Published Price 15.00
Type Book


In a review of "That Old Sinner" by Frank Sweeney, I observed that every company history should be written in two parts, Patterson style and Sweeney style. The 5- Minute Bell takes on the latter task in relation to the Waterford and Tramore Railway the former having been ably done by the well known railway historians Harold Fayle and Alan T Newham. In addition to setting out the company history, the author delves into the staff running the system, locomotives, rolling stock, anecdotes about the railway and the uses its passengers put it to, accidents and the ultimate closure, the latter a chapter in which no punches are pulled. The book is well illustrated and identified many unusual features of the line that I was unaware of. The book is a reasonable look at this short isolated line which was never physically connected to the rest of the railway network. However, there were a few assertions that I would take the author to task over. These were: On p. 11, he states that the British gauge issue had been resolved by 1843. The matter was determined by a Royal Commission in 1845. P.13 states that an Act of Parliament was necessary to allow a new railway to be built. This is not strictly correct both the Atmospheric Railway in Dublin and a line in Co. Derry were built without Acts of Parliament. The final point which is not correct is on p. 113 where the author repeats the red herring that the EU requires railways to be left in situ for 10 years. I checked this with the European Commission and they advise that there is no such EU requirement.


Return to Railway Book Reviews


COPYRIGHT EWAN DUFFY 2015 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. COPYRIGHT SUBSISTS IN THIS REVIEW. YOU MAY NOT SAVE A COPY OF THIS AND/OR REPRODUCE THIS IN ANY PUBLICATION AND/OR ON ANY WEBSITE WITHOUT THE EXPRESS WRITTEN CONSENT OF EWAN DUFFY. STANDARD CHARGE FOR REPRODUCTION IS EUR100,000.00